"Can't disagree with any of that. I don't think we'll fully appreciate Mr Gerrard until we don't have him any more. This guy bleeds red. Lets all enjoy him while we still have him around, cos nothing lasts forever......"
"Let me just put it this way. Stevie is so good, he could walk into any of the past L'pool team. And not so long ago, he was hailed as the best player in the world, by none other than Zidane himself. Legend.
.telegraph.co.uk/sport/football/teams/liverpool/4984191/Liverpools-Steven-Gerrard-hailed-as-worlds-best-player-by-Zinedine-Zidane.html"
"Gerrard is Liverpools best ever player, Dalglish had better players around him. Do u think if kenny had the players we've had in the last 10 years around him in he'd have won as much, I don't think so. If Gerrard had Barnes, Rush an all them fantastic players around him, he'd have won a lot of league les. Gerrard has carried liverpool his entire career, amazing talent!! YNWA "
"Stevie, Kenny and Barnesy upthere to watch any other LFC player from the top to the down! None as these three! Under the guidance of BR, Stevie G can become even the best within the next 5-6 years! YNWA SG"
"Sorry but for me Dalglish is number one . Gerrard is a legend and he has not retired yet but Dalglish was a brilliant player for Liverpool and also did it as a player/manager . We have been lucky to have had both at this wonderful Club."
"BOTH CLASS ACTS BUT I HAVE TO AGREE THAT KENNY HAD MORE QUALITY AROUND HIM. DON'T LIKE PEOPLE SAYING STEVIE.G HAS 'CARRIED' US DESPITE HIS MASSIVE INFLUENCE. WHEN THE TEAM HAS WON WITHOUT STEVIE IT'S ALWAYS BEEN OVERLOOKED. "
"Fantastic response and positive comments for a change, Carra will always back Stevie they came through the ranks together faithful to the end.We have been so fortunate to have had such great players in our past and present teams, enjoy what you have. Tomorrow is another day for someone else to stand upto the plate and give their all for this great football club of ours LFC. YNWA."
"Definately the best player of the last 15-20 yrs but better than Kenny? Not for me. Cant even see Stevie in any of the teams pre 1986. They were winning TEAMS, not Squads so hard to see who he'd replace when things were basically perfect."
"Who is the best Gerrard or Dalglish ? I think both LEGENDS would agree with this A LEGEND that needs our help is ANNE WILLIAMS 21664 signatures on the e-peion PLEASE BRING FORWARD KEVIN WILLIAMS INQUEST. This poor lady is fighting for justice for the 96 and her life, Only half of the anfeild capacity have signed this the rest of you should be ASSAMED OF YOURSELFS. Sign the e-peion now YNWA "
"On Carra's own reasoning, Bobby Charlton will have to be downgraded because he played in a successful England team! It's the wrong way to evaluate players - it wasn't Dalglish's fault he happened to be brilliant in a brilliant team! "
"what a stupid, idiotic question who is over who I am loosing my respect of JC to face this situation at all in the history of LFC KKD is the top and not only because he was the best player but for his managerial work and his doing after Hillsborough LFC.com starts to loose the way "
"now we live hard times we should be united and not diveded such a fool question JC and noneone at the club should not dethrone KD someone over 700 appareaces should be aware of that End of"
""CAPTAIN FANTASTIC! How he hasn't (yet) won World Footballer of the Year is incredible. YNWA! Can't believe "Would I Lie To You" had k mac k on it last night. Couldn't watch it. Disgraceful! J496""
"Hard to compare but Kenny's done better, though with better players around him.
highway36- I like the show and turned over instead(my guess is it was filmed a while ago, still...)The irony was he was on a show about lying. I wish/hope they ripped him to shreads."
"And with respect to BarryPr in time Gerrard will be recognised as the greatest. I was privaleged enough to see Kenny back int he day but Gerrard is the best ever LFC player.
"
"In this era, Stevie is the best player for LFC. KD was the best player in his era.
I think it it unfair to compare the two. The game is played differently and with different systems as time evolved."
"Steven is very special but Kenny was our best ever player, one of our best managers and beyond doubt the greatest ambassador the club could ever have."
"i just loved having two legends working side by side, king kenny must be brought back into the club to do some ambassador role.
kenny and stevie you are my heroes.
ynwa"
"Is it really a two horse race. He may not have been at the club as long as Kenny or Stevie, and lost lots of fans in his time as manager, but for sheer all round class, as player and captain, my vote goes to Souness. He won the treble in 1984 almost single handed (Kenny had a bad season) and those he played with (Ronnie Whelan for example in his book)will tell what a great player he was."
"Glorious LFC. Read your comments again. You criticise JC for this 'foolish question' about who is best and then go on to say KD is best. It is a psychological truth that we criticise in others what we don't like in ourselves. If you don't like the question don't join in with an answer. As with all these debates it is always a matter of opinion."
"Having watched all the great players in the last 50 years, Gerard is the most complete footballer I have ever seen anywhere. He can do everything to a high standard. That's why I rate him above ALL others not only KK."
Comments
Submit your views in the box below. Alternatively, you can debate these issues with fellow fans on our Message Boards or blog about them on The Kop
The views expressed here are not those of Liverpool Football Club (read more)
You must be over thirteen years of age to post a commment
You must have set a nickname to post a comment.
Click here to set your nickname.
Sorry, comments are closed for this article.
Sorry, new comments are closed for this article.
You must accept the Terms & Conditions before posting a comment
3rd Nov 2012 8:50